Kill or spare Arnold: the story doesn’t care
Pick whichever fits your Jason. The only thing that changes is your Criminal Profile, per Game Rant.
What each choice does
After the foot chase you corner Arnold at the end of a jetty and get the choice.
| You | Criminal Profile | Story |
|---|---|---|
| Shoot him | Hardened | Same |
| Spare him | Restrained | Same |
| Wait, he swims off | Restrained | Same |
Kenton either way
Next time you see Brian, he sets Jason up with Kenton. That opens Island Dreams and Kenton’s treasure dives. Radio Times confirms you meet Kenton whichever way you go.
Frequently asked questions
Should you kill or spare Arnold in GTA 6?
Either is fine. Killing him puts Hardened on your Criminal Profile. Sparing him, or waiting until he swims away, puts Restrained. The story carries on the same way.
What happens if you wait?
Arnold swims off. That counts the same as sparing him.
What comes after Hey Arnold!?
Brian introduces Jason to Kenton, which unlocks Island Dreams and, through it, treasure hunting.